Personally, I disagree with the death penalty. I understand that there are circumstances in which this would seem to be a good solution, but America's existing systematic racism overrides its advantages. It's immoral on multiple levels, but the foundation it resonates with the most is Authority. It is immoral on the basis that people in power are being allowed to dictate the lives of others to the degree of how long that life will continue, and that they are doing that from a racist point of view.
Currently, the United States has 25% of the world's prisoner population, at 2.3 million incarcerated. Of those 2.3 million, 1 million are African American. While many attribute this to there simply being a higher rate of crime within African American communities, in reality they are incarcerated at nearly six times the rate that whites are and are given much lengthier sentencing for their crimes. The death penalty has similar statistics. Of the existing cases of executions for interracial murders, 31 involved a white defendant and a black victim. 289 black defendants were executed for the murders of white people.
Until we can establish an unbiased and unprejudiced legal system, the death penalty is a problematic discipline that gives more power to institutionalized racism and oppression.
Sources:
http://www.naacp.org/pages/criminal-justice-fact-sheet
http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/documents/FactSheet.pdf
Does Death Penalty Save Lives? A New Debate by Adam Liptak
Liptak presents evidence that shows the death penalty's effect on homicide rates. Statistics show that 3 to 18 murders can be prevented with each executed murderer, however those statistics are very skewed. A number of sloppy or sketchy points of data render the study's results "fragile."
Death Penalty is a Deterrent by George E. Pataki
Pataki argues that the death penalty serves as a deterrent from crime and keeps citizens safe. He says that without the death penalty, citizens lived in fear because crime went largely unpunished.
What do we and don't we deserve as humans? What rights do we all have, and what authority can take those away?
Emma Moral Issues
Monday, October 6, 2014
Monday, September 29, 2014
Sumner Post
I remember a trend of certain Blake students making inflammatory Facebook posts and public statements last year. They were typically centered around racial issues at Blake and in pop culture and they angered a lot of students who believed the statements made were far fetched. I realized that there is a harmful folkway at Blake that allows us to be blind to the cruelty that has been institutionalized, specifically in our own community.
These posts were usually a topic of debate for days, if not weeks, afterwards, with comment threads that could get into the hundreds. It was confusing as to why these topics sparked such controversy in a place where racism is treated as a small issue that mostly takes place in extreme situations, completely removed and unrelated to our community. Why did people care so much, and why were we so offended when someone accused us of participating in a centuries old system of oppression? Were we really so surprised?
Because these conversations and concepts were unique, they allowed for a moral matrix to be made. The people posting were characterized as dumb and attention seeking "social justice warriors." Even if their post wasn't intentionally inflammatory, it was characterized like the ones that were. The bad posts created a stereotype for all students who wanted to bring up the same issues, or who wanted to point out any flaw in our perceived notion of political correctness and sensitivity. The respondents almost seemed eager to find a reason not to address racism on a personal scale.
I agreed that a fair number of these posts/statements were provocative just for the sake of being provocative, but I also found that many reactions got out of hand. The responses could be borderline violent and many people resorted to personally offending those involved in the discussion, rather than share any educated opinions.
I agreed that a fair number of these posts/statements were provocative just for the sake of being provocative, but I also found that many reactions got out of hand. The responses could be borderline violent and many people resorted to personally offending those involved in the discussion, rather than share any educated opinions.
I saw that when the conversations happened on Facebook, many people were unafraid to state their opinion abrasively. However, I only heard of one person confronting one of the posters in real life, while I was able to involuntarily overhear other students gossiping about who posted what. These were never actually well intended conversations about the issues the original poster tried to bring up, but instead about issues of following the status quo or "playing the race/gender/sexuality card." This showed to me that people didn't actually care whether there was racism at Blake, they just cared that someone else wanted to change how they had to think about the world.
On one hand, many of the people who made the original posts were harsh and the way they went about bringing racism into the spotlight was questionable. On the other hand, I felt that a lot of people took their reactions too far and used one person's stance as a reason to not care about these issues at all, which was understandable.
It's understandable that our community wouldn't want to face the prejudices and insensitivities that we consider normal, and it's understandable that we would want to find reason to ignore the long history of oppression and racism that lead us to believe what we do is okay. Life is much, much easier when we stay within our comfort zone, even while others are being mistreated. It is incredibly easy and satisfying to let your privilege guide your thinking, and to even forget about the issues that many people face. However, it's really not okay to think this way. It's a harmful folkway and allows for cruelty to become institutionalized, because it allows those in power to keep their own interests in mind while others are forced to suffer.
Tuesday, September 9, 2014
I talked to my younger sister about an experience she had last year with exploding at her classmates for disrespecting their Chinese teacher. They made fun of the teacher's accent and didn't pay attention or take the class seriously, which distressed my younger sister, an ambitious student. She could tell that her peers didn't care or didn't understand the weight of their actions and how they affected her teacher. Their ignorance reminded me of 'The Conscience of Huckleberry Finn' by Jonathan Bennett. However, these students, unlike Huckleberry Finn or Heinrich Himmler, had no visible sympathy for the victim of their actions and bad morality ruled.
Her moment relates most to the 'Authority' foundation of morality, which surprised me because I expected her to hold 'Harm/Care' and 'Fairness/Reciprocity' in a higher regard because she's younger and therefore has a substantially larger amount of experience of immorality in the first two foundations versus the rest. However, while telling me her thoughts and answering my questions, she focused on her peers' disrespect to the teacher's authority the most, and didn't specifically touch on the unfairness or harm that may have contributed towards the overall immorality of the situation, except in regards to her fellow students' feelings.
My sister felt guilty for the harm she may have inflicted by yelling at her classmates, and regretted both the embarrassment and the immorality she felt. She still feels that she could have handled the situation differently, and says that her only redemption was people admitting, after a few months, that they understand what she meant and regret acting immorally. It reminded me of the Fernando Pessoa quote, “No intelligent idea can gain general acceptance unless some stupidity is mixed in with it.” However, it also made me think of the first chapter of our Vices & Virtues textbook. Its author talks about only being able to free yourself from institutionalized or systematic oppression by standing up to those in power or removing yourself from the situation, with much more emphasis on the fight facet of 'fight or flight.' My sister's actions fall underneath the fight category, but I don't think that the results were in any way similar to the ones detailed in Vices & Virtues. I originally didn't agree with the author, and talking to my sister helped reinforce my opinion that institutionalized oppression isn't subsided when those not in power stand up to those in power.
Her experience made me wonder more about fight or flight. Although I personally do not believe that fighting is the answer, I wonder if the author's philosophy is more legitimate in other circumstances?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)